Is our legal system becoming too influenced by the culture of psychotherapy – of achieving 'closure' in the courtroom, emotional release and catharsis, working through trauma – ideas extraneous to law and the proper purpose of the courts, even threatening the adversarial system as a whole? Or have insights drawn from psychiatry and psychoanalysis added much-needed depth to law’s own understanding of the human psyche?
Drawing on a range of expertise – judicial and psychoanalytic, from neuroscience and forensic psychiatry to historians of mental health and champions of the ‘victim’s voice’ in court - Helena Kennedy examines the deep and sometimes uneasy relationship between law (especially the criminal law) psychotherapy and the mind doctors, and asks what its proper purpose might be.
Contributors include: psychotherapist Adam Phillips, former Lord Justice of Appeal Alan Moses, forensic psychiatrist Nigel Eastman, writer and historian Lisa Appignanesi, Victims Commissioner Baroness Newlove and Harvard neuroscientist Lisa Feldman Barrett.
Listen again here
Presenter: Helena Kennedy QC
Producer: Simon Hollis
A Brook Lapping Production for BBC Radio 4.